Zach Smith was an assistant coach at Ohio State until allegations of domestic abuse over the summer caused him to be fired by the university. Smith has denied these allegations and continues to claim that they are false despite all signs pointing towards them being true. Smith’s recent behavior on Twitter has not done much to help his claims, but Brett McMurphy’s recent report accusing Smith of using a racial slur towards Trevon Grimes has given Smith newfound credibility that he hasn’t earned.
On Sunday Zach Smith got on Twitter and finally decided that it was time to show the world the type of people Tom Herman and his wife Michelle are. Smith threw out multiple accusations saying Tom had cheated on his wife with an Asian masseuse and an Iowa State recruiting girl. Smith made multiple tweets calling Herman a “snitch” and a “hypocrite” and then posted a lengthy text message tirade he sent to Herman where Tom’s only response was, “Ok. Cool Hook ‘Em!🤘🏼” Michelle Herman never responded to Smith directly, but did change her twitter bio to read, #OkCoolHookEm 🤘🏼 which shows her solidarity with her husband despite Smith’s tweets painting their relationship as rocky at best.
Smith’s Twitter outburst likely would have been a meme for a couple days and then mostly forgotten if Brett McMurphy hadn’t also resurfaced with his report that Smith called Trevon Grimes a racial slur. Smith of course denied the allegations, but this time he had far more support. Grimes, along with Ohio State administration and players also denied the allegations against Smith. McMurphy’s main source in the report was Trevon Grime’s father, LeBron Grimes, who Trevon claims he has not had contact with for the last two years. However, McMurphy stood by his reporting despite multiple players who witnessed the incident denying that a racial slur was used.
This report came just two days after Smith’s twitter tirade and immediately Zach Smith jumped into action calling McMurphy a “phony” and also calling McMurphy a liar. This time around people seemed to side with Smith, although the reactions of the Ohio State players certainly helped. Smith seemed to come away from this set of allegations without incident, but McMurphy’s credibility was definitely hurt by the backlash his report received.
For me however, all of this happened way too close together to just be a coincidence. Smith takes to Twitter to accuse Tom Herman of cheating on his wife, and then two days later a report comes out which accuses Smith of using racial slurs against his players. It’s far too convenient that Smith decided that Sunday afternoon was the time to unleash the “truth” and expose Herman. Luckily for Smith no one who was actually there that day corroborated McMurphy’s report, but there’s a far bigger story behind this that just shows you the type of person Zach Smith is.
Smith had to have found out about these upcoming allegations, or maybe he knew that a new McMurphy report against him was coming. Whatever the case, we know McMurphy contacted Trevon Grimes before the report was published to get a statement from him, and it wouldn’t surprise me if word got around to Smith, or Grimes himself told him that McMurphy was making another report on him. Grimes after all was a wide receiver at Ohio State, and Smith was the receivers coach so they very likely had each other’s phone numbers, and at least a working relationship until Grimes transferred to Florida. Plus the grapevines between coaches and players run very deep in college football. For McMurphy to contact so many people for his report and not a word of it to make its way to Smith would be very unlikely.
The rest of this is entirely speculation, but I think it follows that Smith attempted to formulate some kind of plan to deal with this report. Whether Smith’s twitter outburst was planned by him and his lawyer, or all the product of Smith’s thinking is unknown, but to me the allegations against Herman were Smith’s way of creating smoke ahead of a new McMurphy report. After the report came out Smith realized that he wasn’t going to be attacked for these allegations, and backed down from the Hermans. Ever since the McMurphy report Smith hasn’t said anything about the allegations he made on Sunday and has instead focused all of his attention on McMurphy, along with his lawyer.
Obviously there is no way of knowing what Smith’s plan was, but to me it’s clear he wanted to use Tom and Michelle to deflect attention away from him and save face. He still has not been found guilty of any domestic abuse charges, but his actions are definitely not the actions of a man looking to prove his innocence. Zach Smith still views himself as a victim despite his ex-wife’s obvious torment through all of this. Smith is still attempting to manipulate people, but thanks to McMurphy’s report he has gained credibility despite the fact that none of McMurphy’s reports on Smith’s domestic abuse have been shown to be false. This whole situation has become a net positive for Smith, and unless some more information about his domestic abuse surfaces, he likely won’t face any repercussions for it.


(Image from Youtube.com)